Month: August 2008

  • ART WARS continued:

    Three Times


    "Credences of Summer," VII,

    by Wallace Stevens, from
    Transport to Summer (1947)

    "Three times the concentred
         self takes hold, three times
    The thrice concentred self,
         having possessed
    The object, grips it
         in savage scrutiny,
    Once to make captive,
         once to subjugate
    Or yield to subjugation,
         once to proclaim
    The meaning of the capture,
         this hard prize,
    Fully made, fully apparent,
         fully found."

    Stevens does not say what object he is discussing.

    One possibility --

    Bertram Kostant, Professor Emeritus of Mathematics at MIT, on an object discussed in a recent New Yorker:

    "A word about E(8).
    In my opinion, and shared by others, E(8) is the most magnificent
    'object' in all of mathematics. It is like a diamond with thousands of
    facets. Each facet offering a different view of its unbelievable
    intricate internal structure."

    Another possibility --

    The 4x4 square

      A more modest object --
    the 4x4 square.

    Update of Aug. 20-21 --

    Symmetries and Facets

    Kostant's poetic comparison might be applied also to this object.

    The natural rearrangements (symmetries) of the 4x4 array might also be described poetically as "thousands of facets, each facet offering a different view of... internal structure."

    More precisely, there are 322,560 natural rearrangements-- which a poet might call facets*-- of the array, each offering a different view of the array's internal structure-- encoded as a unique ordered pair of symmetric graphic designs. The symmetry of the array's internal structure is reflected in the symmetry of the graphic designs. For examples, see the Diamond 16 Puzzle.

    For an instance of Stevens's "three times" process, see the three parts of the 2004 web page Ideas and Art.

    * For the metaphor of rearrangements as facets, note that each symmetry (rearrangement) of a Platonic solid corresponds to a rotated facet: the number of symmetries equals the number of facets times the number of rotations (edges) of each facet--

    Platonic solids' symmetry groups
    The metaphor of rearrangements as facets breaks down, however, when we try to use it to compute, as above with the Platonic solids, the number of natural rearrangements, or symmetries, of the 4x4 array. Actually, the true analogy is between the 16 unit squares of the 4x4 array, regarded as the 16 points of a finite 4-space (which has finitely many symmetries), and the infinitely many points of Euclidean 4-space (which has infinitely many symmetries).

    If Greek geometers had started with a finite space (as in The Eightfold Cube), the history of mathematics might have dramatically illustrated Halmos's saying (Aug. 16) that

    "The problem is-- the genius is-- given an infinite question, to think
    of the right finite question to ask. Once you thought of the finite
    answer, then you would know the right answer to the infinite question."

    The Greeks, of course, answered the infinite questions first-- at least for Euclidean space. Halmos was concerned with more general modern infinite spaces (such as Hilbert space) where the intuition to be gained from finite questions is still of value.

  • For the Journeyers to the East:

    The Revelation Game
    Revisited

    (See also Jung's
    birthday
    .)

    Google logo, Aug. 18, 2008: Dragon playing Olympic ping pong

    Lotteries on
    August 17,
    2008
    Pennsylvania
    (No revelation)
    New York
    (Revelation)
    Mid-day
    (No belief)
    No belief,
    no revelation

    492

    Chinese
    Magic
    Square:

    4 9 2
    3 5 7
    8 1 6

    (See below.)

    Revelation
    without belief

    423

    4/23:

    Upscale
    Realism:
    Triangles
    in Toronto

    Evening
    (Belief)
    Belief without
    revelation

    272

    Rahner
    on Grace

    (See below.)

    Belief and
    revelation

    406

    4/06:

    Ideas
    and Art

    No belief, no revelation:
    An encounter with "492"--

    "What is combinatorial mathematics?
    Combinatorial mathematics, also referred to as combinatorial analysis
    or combinatorics, is a mathematical discipline that began in ancient
    times. According to legend the Chinese Emperor Yu (c. 2200 B.C.)
    observed the magic square


    4 9 2


    3 5 7


    8 1 6

    on the shell of a divine turtle...."

    -- H.J. Ryser, Combinatorial Mathematics, Mathematical
    Association of America, Carus Mathematical Monographs 14 (1963)

    Belief without revelation:
    Theology and human experience,
    and
    the experience of "272"--

    From Christian
    Tradition Today
    ,
    by
    Jeffrey C. K. Goh
    (Peeters Publishers, 2004), p. 438:

    "Insisting that theological statements are not simply deduced
    from
    human experience, Rahner nevertheless stresses the experience of grace
    as the 'real, fundamental reality of Christianity itself.' 272

    272  'Grace' is a key category
    in Rahner's theology.  He has
    expended a
    great deal of energy on this topic, earning himself the title, amongst
    others, of a 'theologian of the graced search for meaning.' See G. B.
    Kelly (ed.), Karl Rahner, in The Making of Modern Theology
    series
    (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1992)."

  • ART WARS continued:

    "Maybe Escher
    could have done it.
    "

    Escher, 'Verbum,' detail

    Detail from
    Escher's
    Verbum

    ("In Touch with God")

    The title link of this entry
    leads, via a Log24 entry, to
    a story by Robert A. Heinlein.

    For those who, like Rick Warren
    (shown below in a current news page),

    TIME photo of preacher Rick Warren embracing the Republican candidate (on his right) and the Democratic candidate (on his left)

    prefer Jewish narratives,
    I recommend

     1. Kesher Talk's "Dick Morris:
    Flaming Sword of Vengeance
    "

    2. Eyes on the Prize

    3. Triangulation.

  • Halmos on Depth in Mathematics:

    Seeing the Finite Structure

    The following supplies some context for remarks of Halmos on combinatorics.

    From Paul Halmos: Celebrating 50 years of Mathematics, by John H. Ewing, Paul Richard Halmos, Frederick W. Gehring, published by Springer, 1991--

    Interviews with Halmos, "Paul Halmos by Parts," by Donald J. Albers--

    "Part II: In Touch with God*"-- on pp. 27-28:

    The Root of All Deep Mathematics

    "Albers. In the conclusion of 'Fifty Years of Linear Algebra,' you wrote: 'I am inclined to believe that at the root of all deep mathematics there is a combinatorial insight... I think that in this subject (in every subject?) the really original, really deep insights are always combinatorial, and I think for the new discoveries that we need-- the pendulum needs-- to swing back, and will swing back in the combinatorial direction.' I always thought of you as an analyst.

    Halmos: People call me an analyst, but I think I'm a born algebraist, and I mean the same thing, analytic versus combinatorial-algebraic. I think the finite case illustrates and guides and simplifies the infinite.

    Some people called me full of baloney when I asserted that the deep problems of operator theory could all be solved if we knew the answer to every finite dimensional matrix question. I still have this religion that if you knew the answer to every matrix question, somehow you could answer every operator question. But the 'somehow' would require genius. The problem is not, given an operator question, to ask the same question in finite dimensions-- that's silly. The problem is-- the genius is-- given an infinite question, to think of the right finite question to ask. Once you thought of the finite answer, then you would know the right answer to the infinite question.

    Combinatorics, the finite case, is where the genuine, deep insight is. Generalizing, making it infinite, is sometimes intricate and sometimes difficult, and I might even be willing to say that it's sometimes deep, but it is nowhere near as fundamental as seeing the finite structure."

    Finite Structure
     on a Book Cover:

    Walsh Series: An Introduction to Dyadic Harmonic Analysis, by F. Schipp et. al.

    Walsh Series: An Introduction
    to Dyadic Harmonic Analysis
    ,
    by F. Schipp et al.,
    Taylor & Francis, 1990

    Halmos's above remarks on combinatorics as a source of "deep mathematics" were in the context of operator theory. For connections between operator theory and harmonic analysis, see (for instance) H.S. Shapiro, "Operator Theory and Harmonic Analysis," pp. 31-56 in Twentieth Century Harmonic Analysis-- A Celebration, ed. by J.S. Byrnes, published by Springer, 2001.

    Walsh Series
    states that Walsh functions provide "the simplest non-trivial model for harmonic analysis."

    The patterns on the faces of the cube on the cover of Walsh Series above illustrate both the Walsh functions of order 3 and the same structure in a different guise, subspaces of the affine 3-space over the binary field. For a note on the relationship of Walsh functions to finite geometry, see Symmetry of Walsh Functions.

    Whether the above sketch of the passage from operator theory to harmonic analysis to Walsh functions to finite geometry can ever help find "the right finite question to ask," I do not know. It at least suggests that finite geometry (and my own work on models in finite geometry) may not be completely irrelevant to mathematics generally regarded as more deep.

    * See the Log24 entries following Halmos's death.

  • A classic now online:

    'Magister Ludi,' or 'The Glass Bead Game,' by Hermann Hesse
    Magister Ludi
    (The Glass Bead Game)
    is now available for
    download in pdf or
    text format at Scribd.

    "How far back the historian wishes to place the origins and antecedents
    of the Glass Bead Game is, ultimately, a matter of his personal choice.
    For like every great idea it has no real beginning; rather, it has
    always been, at least the idea of it. We find it foreshadowed, as a dim
    anticipation and hope, in a good many earlier ages. There are hints of
    it in Pythagoras, for example, and then among Hellenistic Gnostic
    circles in the late period of classical civilization. We find it
    equally among the ancient Chinese, then again at the several pinnacles
    of Arabic-Moorish culture; and the path of its prehistory leads on
    through Scholasticism and Humanism to the academies of mathematicians
    of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries and on to the Romantic
    philosophies and the runes of Novalis's hallucinatory visions. This
    same eternal idea, which for us has been embodied in the Glass Bead
    Game, has underlain every movement of Mind toward the ideal goal of a
    universitas litterarum, every Platonic academy, every league of an
    intellectual elite, every rapprochement between the exact and the more
    liberal disciplines, every effort toward reconciliation between science
    and art or science and religion. Men like Abelard, Leibniz, and Hegel
    unquestionably were familiar with the dream of capturing the universe
    of the intellect in concentric systems, and pairing the living beauty
    of thought and art with the magical expressiveness of the exact
    sciences. In that age in which music and mathematics almost
    simultaneously attained classical heights, approaches and
    cross-fertilizations between the two disciplines occurred frequently."

     -- Hermann Hesse

    Author's dedication:

    to the Journeyers
    to the East

    Related material:

    The Ring of the Diamond Theorem

    Ring Theory

  • Annals of Philosophy:

    One Year Ago
    in this journal --

    Commentary by Richard Wilhelm
    on I Ching Hexagram 32:

    Hexagram 32, Duration, of the I Ching

    Duration

    "Duration is... not a state of rest, for mere
    standstill is
    regression. Duration is rather the self-contained and therefore
    self-renewing movement of an organized, firmly integrated whole [click on link for an example], taking
    place in accordance with immutable laws and beginning anew at every
    ending."

    Richard Wilhelm's grave. Note the eight I Ching trigrams.

    Richard Wilhelm's grave:
    Note the eight I Ching
    trigrams surrounding
    the globe.

    Globe at opening of 2008 Beijing Olympics

    Globe at the
    Beijing 2008 Olympics
    Opening Ceremony

    The eight trigrams
    were perhaps implied in
    the opening's date, 8/8/8.

  • Happy 8/8/8:

    Weyl on symmetry, the eightfold cube, the Fano plane, and trigrams of the I Ching

    Click on image for details.

  • Review:

    From the last link within the last link of yesterday's entry:

    "Review the concepts of integritas, consonantia, and claritas in Aquinas...."

    Review also the properties of the number six that appears in today's date.

    For such properties, see the page of Log24 entries that end on September 6, 2006, with "Hamlet's Transformation."

    Happy Feast of the Transfiguration.

  • Mathematics and Narrative, continued:

    Published Today:

    Cover of  'The Last Theorem,' a novel by Arthur C. Clarke and Frederik Pohl

    The Last Theorem
    , a novel by
    Arthur C. Clarke and Frederik Pohl

    From the publisher's description:
    "The Last Theorem is a story of one man’s mathematical obsession,
    and a celebration of the human spirit and the scientific method. It is
    also a gripping intellectual thriller....

    In 1637, the French mathematician Pierre de Fermat scrawled a note in
    the margin of a book about an enigmatic theorem: 'I have discovered a
    truly marvelous proof of this proposition which this margin is too
    narrow to contain.' He also neglected to record his proof elsewhere.
    Thus began a search for the Holy Grail of mathematics-- a search that
    didn’t end until 1994, when Andrew Wiles published a 150-page proof.
    But the proof was burdensome, overlong, and utilized mathematical
    techniques undreamed of in Fermat’s time, and so it left many critics
    unsatisfied-- including young Ranjit Subramanian, a Sri Lankan with a
    special gift for mathematics and a passion for the famous 'Last
    Theorem.'

    When Ranjit writes a three-page proof of the theorem
    that relies exclusively on knowledge available to Fermat, his
    achievement is hailed as a work of genius, bringing him fame and
    fortune...."

    For a similar third-world fantasy about another famous theorem, see the oeuvre of Ashay Dharwadker.

    Note the amazing conclusion of Dharwadker's saga (thus far)--

    Dharwadker devises a proof of the four-color theorem that leads to...

    Grand Unification
    of the Standard Model
    with Quantum Gravity!

    For further background, see

    Ashay Dharwadker
      and Usenet Postings.

    Clarke lived in Sri Lanka (formerly Ceylon) from 1956 until his death last March.

    For another connection with Sri Lanka, see

    Location, Location, Location
    (July 13, 2005) and
    Bagombo Snuff Box
    (May 7, 2006).