September 27, 2009

  • Today's Sermon:

    A Pleasantly
    Discursive Treatment

    In memory of Unitarian
    minister Forrest Church,
     dead at 61 on Thursday:
    NY Times Sept. 27, 2009, obituaries, featuring Unitarian minister Forrest Church

    Unitarian Universalist Origins: Our Historic Faith--

    "In sixteenth-century Transylvania, Unitarian congregations were established for the first time in history."

    Gravity's Rainbow--

    "For every kind of vampire, there is a kind of cross."

    Unitarian minister Richard Trudeau--

    "... I called the belief that

    (1) Diamonds-- informative, certain truths about the world-- exist

    the 'Diamond Theory' of truth. I said that for 2200 years the strongest evidence for the Diamond Theory was the widespread perception that

    (2) The theorems of Euclidean geometry are diamonds....

    As the news about non-Euclidean geometry spread-- first among mathematicians, then among scientists and philosophers-- the Diamond Theory began a long decline that continues today.

    Factors outside mathematics have contributed to this decline. Euclidean geometry had never been the Diamond Theory's only ally. In the eighteenth century other fields had seemed to possess diamonds, too; when many of these turned out to be man-made, the Diamond Theory was undercut. And unlike earlier periods in history, when intellectual shocks came only occasionally, received truths have, since the eighteenth century, been found wanting at a dizzying rate, creating an impression that perhaps no knowledge is stable.

    Other factors notwithstanding, non-Euclidean geometry remains, I think, for those who have heard of it, the single most powerful argument against the Diamond Theory*-- first, because it overthrows what had always been the strongest argument in favor of the Diamond Theory, the objective truth of Euclidean geometry; and second, because it does so not by showing Euclidean geometry to be false, but by showing it to be merely uncertain." --The Non-Euclidean Revolution, p. 255

    H. S. M. Coxeter, 1987, introduction to Trudeau's book--

    "There is a pleasantly discursive treatment of Pontius Pilate's unanswered question 'What is truth?'."

    As noted here on Oct. 8, 2008 (A Yom Kippur Meditation), Coxeter was aware in 1987 of a more technical use of the phrase "diamond theory" that is closely related to...

    A kind
     of cross:

    Diamond formed by four diagonally-divided two-color squares

    See both
    Theme and
    Variations
    and some more
    poetic remarks,

    Mirror-Play
     of the Fourfold.

    * As recent Log24 entries have pointed out, diamond theory (in the original 1976 sense) is a type of non-Euclidean geometry, since finite geometry is not Euclidean geometry-- and is, therefore, non-Euclidean, in the strictest sense (though not according to popular usage).

September 26, 2009

September 25, 2009

September 24, 2009

September 23, 2009

September 21, 2009

September 20, 2009

September 19, 2009

  • Block that Metaphor, continued:

    Old Year, Raus!

    Also in today's New York Times obituaries index:

     John T. Elson, Editor Who Asked
    "Is God Dead?" at Time, Dies at 78

    John T. Elson and Budd Schulberg

    Wikipedia article on George Polya:

    • Look for a pattern
    • Draw a picture
    • Solve a simpler problem
    • Use a model
    • Work backward

    From the date of Elson's death:

    Cube, 4x4x4

    Four coloring pencils, of four different colors

    Related material:
    "A Four-Color Theorem."

  • A New Year's Prayer...

    Slouching
    Towards Kristen

    Kristen Wiig as Michele Bachmann, SNL Thursday update, Sept. 17, 2009

    Jerusalem Post Interview
    with Charles Krauthammer

    by Hilary Leilea Krieger, JPost Correspondent, Washington

    Krauthammer, a columnist for The Washington Post, is a winner of the Irving Kristol award.

    Jerusalem Post, June 10, 2009:

    Can you talk a little bit about your own Jewish upbringing and sense of Jewishness, and how that influences you? I assume it's a factor in this particular project.

    I grew up in a Modern Orthodox home [in Montreal]. I went to Jewish day school right through high school, so half of my day was spent speaking Hebrew from age six to 16. I studied thousands of hours of Talmud. My father thought I didn't get enough Talmud at school, so I took the extra Talmud class at school and he had a rabbi come to the house three nights a week. One of those nights was Saturday night, so in synagogue Saturday morning my brother and I would pray very hard for snow so he wouldn't be able to come on Saturday night and we could watch hockey night in Canada. That's where I learned about prayer.

    That didn't seem to you to be a prayer that was likely to go unanswered?

    Yeah, I was giving it a shot to see what side God was on.

    And what did you determine?

    It rarely snowed.

    ************************************

    More on Krauthammer's Canadian childhood:

    "His parents were Orthodox and sent him to
     Hebrew day school. He also took
     private Gomorrah lessons twice a week."

    -- "Charles Krauthammer: Prize Writer,"
         by Mitchell Bard

    ************************************

    Also in the Jerusalem Post interview:

    .... What, then, did you mean by a Jewish sensibility?

    ".... In literature it's an interesting question, what's a Jewish novel?"

    My Prayer:

    Private Gomorrah lessons
    with Kristen.

    Background:

    "Heaven Can Wait"
    at Haaretz.com

    Happy Rosh Hashanah
    (and Gemara).

    Update, 5:01 AM Sept. 19

    Before becoming a writer,
    Krauthammer was, his
    Washington Post biography says,
    a resident and then chief resident
    in psychiatry at
    Massachusetts General Hospital.

    Related Metaphors

    This morning's New York Times:

    NY Times obituary for Irving Kristol, with squirrel-and-nuts ad

    MicheleBachmann.com this morning:

    Squirrel with acorns at Michele Bachmann home page, Sept. 19, 2009

    See also:

    James Hillman's "acorn theory"
    of personality development
    (yesterday's entry).